Vault

Share this post

Unforced Errors

www.vaultdigital.xyz

Unforced Errors

Zach Horn
Aug 28, 2022
Share this post

Unforced Errors

www.vaultdigital.xyz

Hetzner, one of the largest centralized cloud providers, made a potentially costly decision yesterday.

They made it publicly known that Ethereum nodes (or any other nodes, or anything blockchain-related) are not welcome on their service. This was announced in a tweet reply, linking to a Reddit post, which waved vaguely towards their Terms of Service.

Here is the exchange:

Twitter avatar for @maggielove_
maggie love @ )'( @maggielove_
Ethereum cannot be decentralized if the stack is not decentralized... Where is the dialogue on this? 69% of hosted nodes on the Ethereum Mainnet, with over 50% of that coming from Amazon Web Services (AWS), over 15% from Hetzner and 4.1% from OVH.
Image
9:31 PM ∙ Aug 25, 2022
1,009Likes254Retweets
Twitter avatar for @Hetzner_Online
Hetzner @Hetzner_Online
@maggielove_ I know this is off topic, but if there are Hetzner customers who are using Ethereum, they should please read this: reddit.com/r/hetzner/comm… --Katie
reddit.comr/hetzner - Comment by u/Hetzner_OL on ”is it allowed to run a crypto block chain node?”23 votes and 137 comments so far on Reddit
8:38 AM ∙ Aug 26, 2022
76Likes27Retweets

Here is the Reddit post linked in the tweet:

The post says hosting an Ethereum node on Hetzner violates their Terms of Service (ToS). They also include “trading.” It also lumps together Proof of Work and Proof of Stake, which are entirely different consensus mechanisms with vastly different resource consumption.

From a PR perspective, this is an unforced error on Hetzner’s part. They host 16% of Ethereum nodes. Pushing these nodes away will send them searching for distributed hosting alternatives (like Akash Network). As distributed networks grow, they become viable alternatives to centralized cloud service providers like Hetzner. The more viable the distributed networks become, the more they undercut the market power of the centralized services. Hetzner is accelerating the transition to distributed networks—at their own expense.

This announcement is more flash than substance. It establishes that hosting Ethereum nodes on Hetzner violates their ToS. Then it states that Hetzner knows they are currently hosting Ethereum nodes and are “internally discussing how we can best address this issue.”

Ultimately, they have taken a public stance that alienates one of the fastest-growing market segments to grandstand for a small group of people who already agree with them.


An ‘elevator pitch’ for decentralization

Centralization concentrates power so that it can be wielded. Decentralization distributes power as a check against despotism.

The spectrum of decentralization.

Proponents of distributed networks are willing to sacrifice personal power to ensure a healthier, more stable society.

People who preserve centralized power structures envision themselves at the center. They are willing to accept a less stable society for a chance at greater personal power for themselves or their group.

We are entering a technological era that will reduce the inefficiency of decentralization enough to begin transitioning to distributed power structures.

Blockchain enables this transition. Computer hardware is becoming distributed enough to create distributed networks for computing power and resources (this is what Akash does). The combination of distributed hardware and distributed networks creates the means to decentralize our digital world—which is increasingly becoming as ‘real’ as the physical world.


Thanks for reading Vault! Subscribe for free to receive new posts.

Share this post

Unforced Errors

www.vaultdigital.xyz
Comments
TopNew

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Zachary Horn
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing